Analytics is telling the Lakers their Big Three of Luka, Austin, and LeBron is not the juggernaut they hoped for and the team plays much better when any combination of just two of their three offensive stars share the court.
While it’s early in the season and the 17–7 Lakers are still are tied for the 4th best record in the West and 5th best in the NBA, the losses exposed the Big Three’s struggles both on offense and defense when playing together. What’s been extremely concerning is all 7 of the Lakers’ losses have been by double digits, a pattern that not only continues to repeat itself but now seems to be happening more often, leading to 2 losses in the last 3 games.
It’s also not like the Lakers’ Big Three starting lineup has been unstoppable or an offensive juggernaut. Even in their 17 wins, the Lakers only managed a 118.0 offensive (#7), 116.7 defensive (#21), and +0.3 net rating (#15).
The problem was exacerbated in their 7 losses, which all were by double digits to teams with young, physical backcourts. In losses, the Lakers had a poor 103.9 offensive (#29), 122.6 defensive (#22), and -18.7 net rating (#29).
The Lakers current 5-man starting lineup of Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves, Rui Hachimura, LeBron James, and Deandre Ayton has played 76 minutes in 6 games with a 107.6 offensive, 120.7 defensive, and -13.1 net rating.
The only lineup that’s played more minutes is the same 5-man lineup but with Marcus Smart instead of LeBron James. That lineup played 80 minutes in 9 games with a 114.6 offensive, 101.1 defensive, and +13.5 net rating.
The Lakers Big Three starting lineup is broken. Let’s see what Redick could do in the short term to put a band aid on the problem, what Pelinka could do at the trade deadline, and whether somebody needs to go to the bench.
WHAT CAN REDICK DO TO FIX LAKERS’ DEFENSE?

…
The move JJ Redick must now make is to start Marcus Smart to give the starting lineup their missing point-of-attack defender, free Austin Reaves from playing that role, and shift Rui Hachimura’ scoring to the bench.
While Smart does not have the prototypical size of a starting small forward, he can still defend up a position and is the Lakers’ best option to replace Rui Hachimura to give the starting lineup an elite lock down defender.
Ironically, the Lakers 5-player lineup of Doncic, Smart, Reaves, James, and Ayton has only appeared for 3 minutes in 1 game, where they posted an offensive rating of 80.0, defensive rating of 200.0, and net rating of -120.0.
Despite that crazy 3-minutes, starting Smart and moving Hachimura to the bench is too obvious a move for Redick to continue to ignore, especially since Smart owns the #1 defensive rating and #1 net rating on the team.
The big advantage of starting Smart is that he, not Reaves, will be guarding the opposing team’s top scorer. Austin’s offense clearly suffered from also having to be the Lakers’ primary on-ball guard defender last two games.
Redick should start Smart for defense, move Hachimura to the bench for offense, and invest minutes in young players with defensive upside like Thiero or Mañon and veterans who play solid defense like Vanderbilt.
Redick should run 10-man rotation with better offense/defense balance. The starters should be Doncic, Reaves, Smart, James, and Ayton with Smith Jr, Thiero/Mañon, LaRavia, Hachimura, and Vanderbilt as backups.
Lakers’ head coach Redick needs to retool his current starting lineup and rotation to play better defense, give more minutes to players who defend, and keep the team winning until Pelinka can make a trade deadline move.
WHAT CAN PELINKA DO TO FIX LAKERS’ ROSTER?

…
To be a legitimate contender, the Lakers need to add two defensive players: an elite 3&D starting small forward to defend bigger wing scorers and a big shot-blocking center who could backup and play alongside Deandre Ayton.
The Lakers’ problem is they do not have the young talent or draft capital needed at this point to trade for those two defenders and could be wise to be patient and wait until draft day next summer to make major moves.
Excluding swaps, which Luka trade and Mark Walter sale have devalued, the Lakers only draft capital right now is one first round and one second round pick, which could be enough to fill one of the two roster holes.
It will be interesting to see whom Rob Pelinka targets before the trade deadline. The abrupt move away from trades to free agency last summer was reportedly driven and approved by Mark Walter’s transition team.
Rumors are already popping up about the Lakers making small moves midseason to fix the roster but saving any blockbuster moves to next summer when they’ll have 3 picks and up to $100 million in cap space.
With Friedman and Zaidi working with Pelinka, the Lakers are expected to heavily rely on analytics to target inexpensive young players with strong two-way 3&D potential whom they could trade for before the deadline.
Eight players LA could target include the Blazers’ Robert Williams, Heat’s Andrew Wiggins, Suns’ Dillon Brooks, Pels’ Herb Jones, Magic’s Jonathan Isaac, Kings’ Keon Ellis, and Clippers’ Kris Dunn and Derrick Jones, Jr.
While the Lakers need moves to be contenders this year, there’s a strong argument the smarter move would be to wait until draft day next summer when they’ll have 3 first round picks plus mega cap space for free agents.
WHICH OF BIG THREE SHOULD COME OFF BENCH?

…
The reality is the Lakers may not be able to build a championship starting lineup with three offense-first stars in Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves, and LeBron James. One of the three may ultimately have to come off the bench.
The problem with building a championship starting starting lineup around the Lakers’ offense-first Big Three is the other two starters need to be an alpha point-of-attack defender and elite shot-blocking defensive center.
Right now, Hachimura is definitely not alpha point-of-attack defender the Lakers need to guard bigger wing scorers nor is Ayton the bruising shot-blocking rim protector the Lakers need to be an elite defensive team.
What would make building a championship starting lineup and rotation easier would be if one of the Lakers Big Three were to come off the bench. That’s what the first quarter data and the analytics are telling the Lakers.
While it’s painful to imagine the Lakers asking Austin Reaves or LeBron James to come off the bench, it’s not impossible to imagine things getting so bad that Reaves or James ends up volunteering to come off the bench.
Ultimately, the Lakers solution is not asking one of the Big Three to come off the bench. It’s asking their Swiss-Army-knife superstar LeBron James to focus almost exclusively on playing defense rather than playing offense. Instead of focusing on offense and resting on defense, Redick needs to convince James to focus on defense and rest on offense. Turn LeBron into an elite 24 minutes per game point-of-attack defender and rim protector.
The Lakers don’t need one of their stars to go to the bench. What they need is their jack-of-all-trades, Swiss-Army-knife superstar LeBron James to let Luka and Austin dominate the offense while he takes care of the defense.






